Are dog shock collars humane?
I have a small pomeranian, and she barks whenever left alone. Understandable, but she disturbs my dad and sister sleeping. I put her in a crate (kennel training) when it’s time for her to go to sleep, and if I am present in the room, (even though i put a sheet over her crate), she knows I’m present and will fall asleep with no barks or whines at all. But, on the other hand if I leave her in the crate, while I’m not present, she will bark and whine and cry FOREVER. What do I do? I can’t go anywhere basically without pissing my sister or my dad off because of the endless crying she does.
Open for suggestions on any other way to prevent her from barking. (Yes I know all the reinforcements, and treats for when she’s quiet BS, I’m talking about something that WORKS.)
Tags: dad, kennel training, pomeranian, reinforcements, sleep, whines
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
People who are against shock collars have never actually felt one.
Have you ever rubbed your feet (in socks) against a carpet and then touched someone else? That’s a static shock. That’s what the collars do.
They are not powerful, they are not painful. It gets your attention, that’s it. I have shocked myself with them many times. Not nearly at the level of a cattle fence (of which I’ve also shocked myself — as kids we PLAYED with the cattle fences!)
They work great, are not "cruel", and stop the needless barking.
Petsafe deluxe is my favorite one.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
There are shock collars that shock the dog at an increasing rate as they continue to bark only for every bark it’s not a consistent shock. I don’t find them in humane it’s like spanking a child
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
they are "humane" enough to be sold, but many people don’t recommend them because if used improperly, they can hurt the dog.
there are bark sprays/collars to where when the dog continually barks, it releases a spritz of some odor that the dog doesn’t like. i forgot what it’s called. check the pet store or ask the local humane society. there’s also good old fashion dog obedience training schools.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
No. Do not use a shock collar on your dog. Try putting a soft tee shirt with your scent on it in her crate for her to cuddle up with. Also, have some soft music playing in the room.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
If used in a respectful manor, not to be abused in any way. Their for before applying it test it on you’re self.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
its like torture for making a sound
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
Train the dog.
Put dog in crate. Give a stuffed Kong or chew. Walk a few feet into the next room. Dog will bark.
The instant the dog is quiet come back into the room. Don’t make a big deal out of it.
Do the same over and over. Gradually the dog should stop barking sooner as it learns barking does not get what she wants. Being quiet works because it causes you to return.
If after practicing several times each day for 3 weeks and it does not work get a citronella collar.
Dogs hate the smell.
Training is best. A citronella collar is more humane than a shock collar.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
Well a humane test would be put the collar around your neck and see if the jolt hurts. Shock collars should be outlawed.
She has separation anxiety. Try contacting a certified dog trainer for some ideas on what training might help reduce the problems.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
Shock collars are cruel and should never be used except by trained professionals.
Your problem has an easy fix: when you leave, put the dog and her crate in your sister’s room. The dog is barking and crying because she’s afraid to be alone. If she’s not alone, she should settle down.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
You could try the Pet safe brand of e-collars. They dont apply an electric shock but a vibrating sensation. I have one for my dog and have tried it on myself first, it does not hurt at all but simply gets the dogs attention. It also has a beeping noise that you use when training and eventually you dont need the shock button because when the dog hears the beep it will know it is doing something wrong. This collar is in no way inhumane and when used properly is a very good training device.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
Have you tried moving her crate into say your sisters room? I bet the dog falls asleep as long as SOMEONE is in the room with her.
Also a radio/tv playing might help.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
Babies cry and whine at night too but you wouldn’t put a shock collar on them. So why would you do it to another living thing that’s doing the same thing for the same reasons?
it’s just mean ):
Try putting your dog in the cage early before anyone goes to sleep. that way she has time to calm down before everyones snoozing.
Or try putting her in the cage for periods during the day so she gets used to being in it more often and is more comfortable getting into there at night
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
I love dogs, but getting them to do what you want can be a real pain. I was pleased to find this report you can download – it seeems to cover most things you’ll need. Hope it’s useful anyway.
Best of luck.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
Hey noticed your questions. Before we got our dog we had a bunch of questions, what kind etc. After getting our pet we had even more questions. How to house train, train to stay in the yard, crate training plus all the questions of how to take care of her. Our neighbor suggested we check out the dog training course sure helped answer all our questions and train our dog. Maybe it’ll be a good fit for you.
Relax and Enjoy
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
I see you have a problem with your dog. My Border collie had a similar issue… But not any more… After talking to my veterinarian to see about a possible solution to the problem… He told me about a program called Dog-Training Secrets other dog owners were using to solve lots dog-related issues. It solved my problem and I’m sure you’ll find this information very useful too.
September 11th, 2011 at 6:46 am
Hi, I’ve been breeding and training dogs, mostly dobermanns and german shepherds, for more than 20 years. There is not a problem I have not come across. I always recommend getting to class, and if this is not possible use a good guide – that means use it, follow it and stick to it !!
Many of my clients and friends have been using Dog Training Academy with fantastic results. Remember – its usually the owner needs more training than the dog. Follow the guides and you will have a happy dog/friend for life.
Good luck